AWS vs. Azure vs. Google Cloud Governance Models

Image for post
Image for post

The deliverability of cloud governance models has improved as public cloud usage continues to grow and mature. These models allow large enterprises to tier and scale their AWS Accounts, Azure Subscriptions and Google Projects across hundreds and thousands of cloud users and services. When we first started talking to customers 5+ years ago, mostly AWS users at the time, they often had a single AWS account for their entire organization and required third-party tools to manage usage and costs by project, line of business or application owner. But now, the “Big 3” cloud providers offer an array of ways for even the largest Fortune 500 enterprises to set up, run and manage their use of the dizzying volume of cloud services.

Why Cloud Governance Models are Important

The main way cloud providers allow cloud administrators to manage and grant access to their services is by leveraging Identity and Access Management (IAM) and providing options for roles and policies that govern both access and usage. IAM lets you grant granular access to specific AWS, Azure and/or Google Cloud resources and helps prevent access to other resources. IAM lets you adopt the security principle of least privilege, where you grant only necessary permissions to access specific resources like VM’s, Databases, Storage, Containers, etc.. With IAM, you manage access control by defining who (identity) has what access (role) for which resource.

In ParkMyCloud, we apply this with Teams and Roles. Admins can create Teams (equivalent to Projects, Applications, or Lines of Business) and can invite a Team Lead to manage that PMC Team, and they can in turn grant users access and set permissions for them, which can then by automated based on policies, usually by leveraging tags but you can use other metadata as well.

What if you want more flexibility with the cloud providers to both manage user access and to more tightly align your cloud services and usage to your organizational structure, projects and applications? Each of the major providers has designed ways for large enterprises to implement a hierarchical usage of cloud users and services that probably can look very similar to that enterprises organization chart. (If you can understand their jargon.)

How AWS, Azure, and Google Apply Cloud Governance Models

We dug into AWS, Azure and Google and this is what we found:

Amazon Web Services (AWS)

  • Tier 1: AWS Organization
  • Tier 2: Organization Unit
  • Tier 3: AWS Accounts
  • Tier 4: Tags
Image for post
Image for post

Microsoft Azure

  • Tier 1: Azure Enterprise Portal
  • Tier 2: Departments
  • Tier 3: Accounts
  • Tier 4: Subscriptions
  • Tier 5: Resource Groups
  • Tier 6: Tags

Google Cloud

  • Tier 1: Organization
  • Tier 2: Folders
  • Tier 3: Projects
  • Tier 4: Resources
  • Tier 6: Tags
Image for post
Image for post

Tips for implementing Cloud Governance Models:

  1. Research and attend web sessions on these cloud governance models to ensure you understand the nuance
  2. Implement your cloud provider’s latest hierarchies and governance models prior to mainstream cloud adoption in your organization
  3. Make sure you run the hierarchies you plan to implement by CloudOps, ITOps, DevOps and FinOps to ensure proper organizational mapping and reporting

The cloud providers have done a pretty good job of documenting their roles, policies and hierarchies and creating a graphical representation of their current hierarchical structures cloud governance models. Of course, none of them use the same terminology — I mean, why would you, too easy, right? (And why does Google rank a ‘Folder’ above a ‘Project’? )

With these options available to you, your cloud operations team can make sure to use this to your advantage when planning new resources, accounts, and use cases within your organization. Let us know your thoughts and if you use any of these models to improve your cloud usage.

Originally published at www.parkmycloud.com on September 1, 2020.

Written by

CEO of ParkMyCloud

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store